Thursday, March 3, 2016

How to Distinguish

Can you tell a Monet from a Renoir? Are you proud of your ability to differentiate Keats from Shelley? If you want to be a true Bel Canto aficionado, train your ears so you can hear the difference between the music written, in those strict Bel Canto forms, by the leading composers of the period: Rossini, Bellini, and Donizetti.

There’s more to Bel Canto than those three, but the repertory of companies like Seattle Opera usually include operas by Gioachino Rossini (everyone loves his Barber of Seville and we’re excited about his hilarious and ridiculous Wicked Adventures of Count Ory), Vincenzo Bellini (we’ve done his Norma , I puritani, and—long ago—La sonnambula) and Donizetti (we’ve just this weekend presented his powerful Maria Stuarda for the first time). Once you’ve learned what to listen for in Bel Canto generally, spend some time figuring out the differences between these three great composers--and what makes each of them great.


A nineteenth-century cartoonist has Rossini, who retired at the age of 40 after writing 40 operas in 20 years, waltzing away with a sack of money from the Paris Opéra, which is burning to the ground now that he has abandoned it.

Classical elegance and grace.
Bel Canto opera straddles the shift, in the early nineteenth century, from the so-called “Classical” period of music to the “Romantic”. Rossini, whose great operas were written between 1813 and 1829, is best considered a Classical composer--in fact he quit writing operas, at age 39, because he couldn’t do the new Romantic thing that had become so trendy. Listen for Classical-era values in Rossini’s music: balance, symmetry, clarity, simplicity, formal grace and elegance. None of that turgid Romantic emotional sloshing to be heard here!

Stephanie Blythe sings the opening of Isabella’s “Pensa alla patria” from Rossini’s The Italian Girl in Algiers.

Bravura performances.
All of Rossini’s operas set up the singers as sports stars, showing off their special skills and ability to perform technically difficult bravura singing. Mediocre performers need not apply. What’s more, because Rossini’s Classical period music doesn’t teem with personal emotion, if the audience is going to invest emotionally in the drama they’ll need charismatic performers up there onstage to care about.

Kate Lindsey sings the conclusion of “Non più mesta” from Rossini’s La Cenerentola.

The Rossini Crescendo.
Rossini’s favorite musical trick is the crescendo, meaning “start soft and get loud”. He uses it most often in his comedies, to accompany increasing mayhem and craziness onstage. In The Barber of Seville you’ll hear several great Rossini crescendos, most famously Basilio’s “Slander” Aria, in which an enormous musical crescendo imitates the effect of an entire town rejecting and ostracizing an individual who gets slandered.

Kevin Langan sings Basilio’s “La Calunnia” from Rossini’s Barber of Seville.


A more recent cartoonist has Bellini lighting the fire that will purge the Druid village of the sinful Norma in his most famous and popular opera.

Sweet melancholy.
Unlike Rossini, Bellini excelled at indulging our emotions musically. All of his operas gravitate toward the same emotion, a Romantic sentiment which was culturally central when his music was all the rage in the 1830s: that sweet, sad, soft, sentimental melancholy of early Romanticism. It’s not about tragedy, it’s too pastel for that. It can feel like yearning, but it’s not a Wagnerian yearning for transcendence—it’s more like homesickness. Romance in Bellini is a gentle thing, more about the feeling you get when my breath tickles the hair on the back of your neck than interactions between other body parts.

Jane Eaglen and Susanne Mentzer sing "Mira, o Norma" from Bellini’s Norma.

All about the breath.
Giuseppe Verdi made a telling, if uncharitable comment, about Bellini: “Bellini is poor, it is true, in harmony and orchestration, but rich in feeling and in an individual melancholy that was all his own. Even in his less familiar operas, there are long, long, long melodies such as no one ever wrote before his day.” The immense length of Bellini’s florid melodic lines--often compared to those of his great friend, Chopin--is one of the key identifying features of his music. It requires supreme breath control to sing these long lines, and many music historians have pointed out that Wagner got the idea of “Endless Melody”—not to mention the shattering, orgasmic climaxes those enormously long lines make possible—from listening to and conducting Bellini, his favorite composer.

Where is the singer supposed to breathe, in an endless Bellini melody like this one?

Lawrence Brownlee sings “A te, o cara” from Bellini’s I puritani.

Don’t overthink it.
Verdi’s point about Bellini’s harmony and orchestration is well-taken (although if Verdi had died at age 34, like Bellini, we’d be making the same complaint about him). Bellini wasn’t the most sophisticated of opera composers; if you go to his works seeking intrigue, humor, suspense, and detailed characterization, you’re likely to be disappointed. A better idea is to relax, let the world go a little fuzzy, get in touch with your feelings, and then let the waves of glorious voice wash over you. Bellini’s characters are usually expressing pretty basic human experiences in song, so as long as you’re emotionally available, this music works.

Arthur Woodley sings the nostalgic “Vi ravisso” from Bellini’s La sonnambula.


Best-known for Lucia di Lammermoor and her beloved mad scene.

Catchy tunes.
Before Verdi came along, Donizetti was the greatest tune-smith of Italian opera. He excelled at writing quirky little melodies that stick in your ear, the first time you hear them, and never go away. They might not be long and florid, like Bellini’s melodies, or graceful and elegant, like Rossini’s; but each one has an individual character which makes it memorable.

William Burden and Aleksandra Kurzak sing “Veranno a te sull’aure” from Lucia di Lammermoor.

Music specific to words.
Again paving the way for Verdi, Donizetti’s music flows from the words more directly than was the case with Rossini or Bellini. “Give me a laundry list and I’ll set it to music,” Rossini was known to say, and sometimes you wonder if he’d even read the words before he wrote the music. And Bellini’s melodies are often so long you can’t understand the words. But in his greatest moments, Donizetti exploited music’s ability to add meaning to text. Listen, for example, to the great burst of sunshine through gloom that comes when Nemorino, who’s been languishing in unrequited love for most of The Elixir of Love, finally realizes that Adina does love him: “M’ama, si, m’ama, lo vedo!” (She loves me, yes, she loves me, I see it!) at 0:57 in this track:

Rafael Rojas sings “Una furtiva lagrima” from The Elixir of Love.

Easy come, easy go.
Donizetti was extremely prolific, having written some 75 operas in the space of about twelve years. (When he heard that Rossini had written The Barber of Seville in two weeks, Donizetti reportedly asked, “What took him so long?”) There have been those who accuse Donizetti of failing to achieve the classical elegance of Rossini, or the exquisite sensibility of Bellini; complaints that Donizetti’s music is coarse, or vulgar, or cheap. Perhaps it is ostentatious, gaudy, even tacky; but if you can sing Tonio’s aria from La fille du régiment, with its 9 high Cs in a row, any audience will love you.

Andrew Stenson sings the conclusion of “Ah, mes amis” from Donizetti’s The Daughter of the Regiment.


Anonymous said...

for some reason the Sound Cloud links in the text are not active; and, there are so many selections in the long Sound Cloud menu that I can't find some of those I am looking for. A pity, as the overall post and opportunity to compare and contrast is very interesting and helpful.

Jonathan Dean said...

Apologies if these SoundCloud links are not cooperating. We've also organized these clips as a discrete SoundCloud playlist at; perhaps that will make things easier.

Jonathan Dean
Seattle Opera

Unknown said...

lacoste online shop
longchamp handbags
under armour curry 3
yeezy boost 350
michael kors outlet
pandora bracelet
nike air zoom pegasus 32
jordan shoes
harden shoes
cheap jordans

raybanoutlet001 said...

nike outlet store
cleveland browns jerseys
ray ban sunglasses outlet
san antonio spurs
seahawks jersey
cleveland cavaliers
mlb jerseys
cheap jerseys for sale
michael kors outlet
polo ralph lauren

jeje said...

jordan 12
converse outlet store
moncler jackets
jordan retro
adidas tubular
cartier bracelet
true religion jeans
kobe 11
cheap jordans
adidas ultra boost 3.0

adidas nmd said...

nike shoes
coach outlet online
ray ban sunglasses
coach factory outlet
ralph lauren outlet
michael kors handbags
coach outlet
burberry outlet
michael kors handbags
nike trainers shoes

raybanoutlet001 said...

ralph lauren polo
mbt shoes
chargers jerseys
oakley sunglasses
jacksonville jaguars jersey
christian louboutin outlet
carolina jerseys
saints jerseys
michael kors handbags
cheap nhl jerseys

Unknown said...

houston texans jerseys
salomon shoes
michael kors uk
air jordan 8
michael kors handbags sale
ralph lauren outlet
colts jerseys
replica watches
ralph lauren polo
ray ban sunglasses outlet

ninest123 said...

adidas outlet
adidas yeezy boost
pandora store
uggs canada
salvatore ferragamo
ralph lauren outlet
ugg boots
pandora charms sale clearance
timberland boots outlet
kate spade handbags

raybanoutlet001 said...

polo pas chère
nike roshe run
moncler jackets
jordan shoes
jordan shoes
ralph lauren outlet
nike outlet
eagles jerseys
true religion outlet

Unknown said...

coach outlet
barcelona jersey
coach outlet
keen shoes
pandora jewelry
canada goose outlet
canada goose jackets
ralph lauren outlet
longchamp handbags
ugg outlet

Unknown said...

nike shoes
adidas yeezy
pandora outlet
mbt shoes
coach outlet
ugg boots clearance
red bottom shoes
christian louboutin shoes
salomon shoes

yanmaneee said...

balenciaga sneakers
michael kors
polo ralph lauren
yeezy shoes
hermes handbags for sale
jordan 11 retro
nike shoes
golden goose outlet
fila shoes
golden goose outlet

yanmaneee said...

air max 270
hermes belt
hogan outlet
westbrook shoes
michael kors handbags
golden goose sneakers
yeezy boost 350
yeezy shoes